|
Reviews:
‘Bus 174’ a tense look Brazillian economic disparity
by Jeana Warren
“Bus 174,” a 133-minute look at the life of a young
Brazilian street kid, is an emotional social commentary. Director
Jose Padilha undertook the project, awarded “Best Documentary”
at the 2002 Sao Paulo Film Festival, after the hijacking of Rio de
Janeiro Bus 174 captured the country’s attention.
The travesty of what is now known in Rio as the Bus 174 incident was
witnessed by millions of Brazilians as it unfolded on television.
Director Padilha included in the film previously aired footage and
appropriately wooven into the story the biography of the troubled
young highjacker, Sandro de Nascimento.
Nascimento was a severely troubled 21-year-old who had lived on the
streets since age 6, and had been in and out of the over-crowded and
ineffective Rio jail system since the age of 16.
The stories of his past and commentaries of his friends offer a raw
and sympathetic look at the reality of police brutality, and the social
and inner distress of many homeless persons.
Director Padilha strikes a satisfying tension by pairing the views
of affluent Brazilians and those of street kids. Deeply poignant reflections,
and recognition that there is no black and white combine into a touching
and revealing portrait.
“Bus 174” is slated to be shown at the Tivoli Starz Film
Center Dec. 12 – 18.
‘A Bibo Reader’: cinematography saves an otherwise
bad film
by Jeana Warren
Leaving the theater after the screening of “A Bibo Reader,”
I began to puzzle over the metaphorical and haphazard pacing of the
movie. I watched as audience members more polite than I threw away
rating ballots, presumably with the higher motive of casting aside
memory along with the paper. Finally, I solved the riddle: I had stayed
awake thanks to the cinematographic excellence of Laszlo Razasz Jr.
Were it not for Razasz, director/producer Peter Forgacs would have
found his audience one person fewer.
Cinematographer Razasz used artistically layered imagery to evoke
emotion and add symbolic elements to director Peter Forgacs’
intonations about Hungarian society in the early to mid-1940s. As
social commentary, the cinematography was far more reaching than the
often too-deep-to-make- sense-of anecdotes presented orally.
Forgacs’ main difficulty is an inability to connect his focus
with the subject of his documentary. Istvan Bibo, who, when quoted,
adds a startling moment of meaning, was a radical politician who held
office in Hungary and served time in prison for supplying Jews with
fake documents during the Holocaust. Unfortunately, Forgacs missed
capturing the power of this story by indulging his own misguided tendencies
to philosophize and over-generalize.
‘I am David’ presented in a tight package, including
a predictable ending
by Sharon Alley
“I am David” is based on the wonderful young-adult book
“North to Freedom,” written by Danish author Anne Holm.
Based in 1952, this movie offers a tale of an unusual 12-year-old
boy, David, who has grown up in a prison camp in Bulgaria. He is helped
to escape from the camp by a sympathetic prison guard who becomes
unable to protect him any further. The guard provides him with a compass,
pocketknife, small bar of soap, a half-loaf of bread and a sealed
letter to deliver to Denmark.
The movie spins the tale of the young boy’s ensuing journey
and is told in typical Hollywood style. Armed with these meager possessions,
it portrays David is portrayed as an intelligent but vulnerable young
innocent evading re-capture by evil, heavily armed soldiers, dodging
interference from well-meaning but misinformed adults and suffering
through an attack by a bullying schoolboy as he tries to single-handedly
fulfill his mission.
The viewer is guided through the story by David’s repeated
flashbacks containing violent scenes as well as pertinent clues for
the viewer. The story is neatly and tightly wrapped up within its
95 minutes. The show was enjoyable and somewhat
predictable. Unfortunately, the limitations of the movie format forced
the director, Paul Feig, to make hard choices when translating the
original book onto the screen.
Time considerations forced out some character-forming events and
totally eliminated most of the intense inner dialogue that David experiences
in the book
I don’t think Feig delved deeply enough into the mental strengths
the boy was forced to develop while living and surviving in the camp.
His movie, in fact, did not match my original perceptions of the book
at all, but perhaps my view would not match his, either.
I loved the book but merely liked the movie, and while I don’t
agree with his interpretation, I do respect his efforts and welcome
his rendition of the book to this year’s film festival.
The lighter side of love and life as seen through the eyes of
of the blind in ‘A Heart Elsewhere’
by Clayton Woullard
Italian Director Pupi Avati must realize the world takes itself too
seriously, especially when it comes to love and the trivialities of
romance. With "A Heart Elsewhere," ("Il Cuore Altrove"
in Italian) Avati exposes love with the shade of humor it deserves,
as a constant pursuit by all.
"A Heart Elsewhere," which premiered in the United States
at the Denver International Film Festival Oct. 10, finds the main
character, Nello Balocchi (Neri Marcore), sent to Bologna from Rome
to teach high school Greek and Latin, and to pursue long-awaited love
and marriage. At 35, Nello remains a virgin and has never married.
The beautiful Angela Gardini (Vanessa Incontrada) comes along to change
all that when Nello falls for her right away. He's lucky in that she's
blind (from some kind of accident), but there's a catch — her
father forbids and warns against any romantic advances.
Nello falls right into Angela's hands, soon discovering he's involved
in the rebound from her previous engagement to Parroco Santa Lucia
(Cesare Cremonini) who is, nonetheless, not in favor of this new relationship.
Angela's desperate avoidance and obvious pettiness adds to the humor
of a situation in which shy Nello always has trouble making sense.
Set in a time between the two World Wars, it's often the small moments
and unique characters, like Nello's roommate, Domenico Riccio (Nino
D'Angelo), a barber who does nothing to help Nello's problems, who
bring levity to the film. Nello's domineering father Cesare Balocchi
(Giancarlo Giannini), a tailor to the Pope and less-than-faithful
husband, adds some humanity to the story, although it's hard to get
the image of his disemboweled Florence detective in "Hannibal"
hanging in the night air, out of my head.
Cesare also presents a conflict for Nello when he finally meets Angela
and is not too pleased to find out she's blind. While Nello's parents'
reaction is one of the most humorous scenes in the film, the sympathy
you've developed already for Nello only deepens as his parents refuse
to sign off on his first true love.
Director Avati, who's written, produced and directed over 30 films,
fielded a few questions from the audience with what he called "bad
English," in lieu of "beautiful Italian."
When asked of the inspiration for "A Heart Elsewhere," Avati
cited an experience with his mother.
"A lot of my movies were written because of my mother,"
he said. "In Bologna she would tell us about the country and
how the blind lived in a house with the nuns. She told of how some
of the men would ride in on their bicycles and come to dance with
these blind women. I started writing a script about these types of
men."
Avati told of how he got into his movie career after an unsuccessful
career as a jazz musician, but his love for jazz music would later
play a part in his filmmaking.
"With the camera, this instrument, I've been able to tell about
my experiences in life, about my memories, about my family and about
jazz music," he said.
In 1990, Avati made a movie about his favorite jazz musician Leon
Bix Beiderbecke, leading him to send a letter to the governor of Iowa.
He asked to make a movie about Beiderbecke, who made his home in Davenport,
Iowa, in a house Avati has since renovated as a historical museum
dedicated to the musician.
While Avati is not afraid to admit his mistakes, citing an international
film he made which was "a great flop," he noted the reason
his latest film is a success, in Italy and several of the other 26
countries where it's been distributed.
"The quality of the acting, I think, is good," he said.
"They're put in a very familiar situation and the descriptions
in the script were very clear."
|